COUNCIL leaders and Chester Cathedral have been forced to go back to the drawing board after ambitious but unpopular plans for a European-style “piazza” were thrown out by planners.
The £3.9m scheme for the city square adjacent to the cathedral was unanimously rejected by Cheshire West and Chester planning committee despite being redrawn.
Following the decision, the authority’s chief executive, Steve Robinson, said: “We will consider the implications of the planning committee’s decision and discuss the issue with the Cathedral authorities and our own planning officers. At this stage, it is impossible to say what the outcome of our talks might be.”
Councillors of all parties supported elements of the scheme, but at the meeting said they were concerned about alterations to the “quiet area” of greenery and trees surrounding the medieval cathedral, removal of the railings and protection of the memorial and possible expanse of York stone attracting skateboarders.
Cllr Adrian Walmsley said he believed many residents of Chester, including Cathedral worshippers, supported his view that there were positive aspects of the current application which were to be greatly welcomed – particularly Cathedral and city coming together. He said: “However, certain specific proposals, like the removal of the grassed area around the Memorial Cross and the emphasis on York stone replacement are not acceptable. If a revised planning application was to be submitted, then it should take into account the many concerns expressed by councillors and residents on these issues.”
Ward Councillor Samantha Dixon said that the application was overwhelmingly opposed by local residents. She said: “The Cathedral needs help but I would argue on behalf of the residents of Chester City – and wider – that this is not the help it needs.”
Dean of Chester, the Very Rev Professor Gordon McPhate, described removal of the barriers between the Cathedral and its city as fully consistent with the Cathedral’s mission statement – “welcome to all” and had urged the committee to approve the plans.
After the meeting rejected the plans, Prof McPhate said: “We are still very keen for the Cathedral and city to work closely together and look forward to developing new ways that can gain wide support and commitment.”
