LEON OSMAN: Worked diligently to find a way into the game but was too often on the periphery before being replaced. Score: 5

STEVEN PIENAAR: Began in lively fashion but faded as the game progressed. Should have been dismissed for a first-half challenge on Mascherano before being sent off in injury time. Score: 5

TIM CAHILL: So often a derby talisman, the Australian missed a good chance just before the interval and was hounded out by the Liverpool defence at set-pieces. Score: 6

LOUIS SAHA: Denied a first-half opening by Reina, but was well shackled by Carragher and Agger as Everton pressed for a leveller. Score: 5

MIKEL ARTETA (sub 40 mins): On for Fellaini, the Spaniard was the visitors’ best player, his midfield probings underlining what Everton have missed. Score: 7

YAKUBU (sub 72 mins): Replaced Saha and fashioned a good opening for himself that solicited a smart save from Reina. Score: 6

VICTOR ANICHEBE (sub 72 mins): Substituted Osman but, posted on the right flank, made little impression up against Insua. Score: 5